cbi: Got convictions in 65-70% of cases in last 10 years: CBI in Supreme Court | India News – Times of India

NEW DELHI: A report card of its performance as a prosecuting agency has been presented under the direction of the Supreme Court, CBI Director Subodh Jaiswal told the court that the agency’s success rate in convicting over the last decade is 65-70%.
Raising serious questions about its “effectiveness” in handling lawsuits, the apex court decided to evaluate its effectiveness when a lawsuit was heard where the agency filed an appeal after a 542-day delay. The court directed its director to provide details of his success rate to the prosecution and submit an affidavit on the effectiveness of the CBI and also provide a record of pending cases.

Jaiswal assured the court that remedial action was being taken to remove the “barrier” and improve performance. He said the delay in one case was “not a reflection of the applicant’s work as the country’s chief investigative agency”.


His affidavit said, “The CBI has been convicted about 65-70% of the time and result of the concerted and coordinated work of the executive officers along with the law officers of the Prosecution Director.”

Jaiswal blamed the judiciary for the delay and referred to the appeal filed by the agency in the alleged 2G scandal in the Delhi High Court. He further noted that the stay was also delayed due to the stay orders issued by the High Court and the Supreme Court and details of 367 cases where these courts stayed proceedings were also given.
“For example, in the case of the 2G scandal, an appeal was filed by the CBI within the 2018 deadline, but to date it has not been granted. (This adds to the difficulty of facing such cases), ”he said.
The CBI director said the agency’s legal department is currently handling 13,291 appeals pending in the Sessions Court, High Court and SC. He has given details of 9,757 pending cases pending in various courts across the country, of which 500 are related to pending trials for more than 20 years and 921 cases are pending in 15-20 years.
Jaiswal added that he was committed to improving the prosecution and that a number of steps had been taken to ensure speedy trials in pending cases, especially those that had been pending for more than 20 years. He further said that soon after taking over as the Director of CBI, one of the major steps was to improve the Prosecution Directorate by meeting all the officials at the level of Assistant Public Prosecutor. Senior Executive Officer, in October, 2021. The CBI’s effort is to bring the current conviction rate to 5% by August 2022.
In September, the Supreme Court said it was not enough for the agency to simply file a lawsuit and investigate, but was forced to ensure that the prosecution was successfully completed. It rejected the CBI’s plea that in an anti-litigation system like India’s, the success rate (in litigation) should not be a factor in determining its effectiveness.
The bench said that the effectiveness of a prosecuting agency is determined on the basis of the case which was brought to a logical conclusion by the agency and took time and directed the CBI director to submit the information which the court would analyze. “Around the world, success rates are being evaluated. What is the need to file a case and conduct an investigation if you cannot sustain the prosecution case? The success rate is very important and needs to be considered, ”the court said.


Read More World News

Keep Reading Latest Breaking News

Source link


Leave a Comment